Writer: Terri Hughes Burton, Ron Milbauer
Director: Peter Ellis
Story: Eric Kripke
Guest Stars: Jovanna Huguet (Bloody Mary / Mary Worthington) , Kristie Marsden (Donna Shoemaker) , Chelan Simmons (Jill) MIchael Teigen (Teacher) Duncan Minett (Steven Shoemaker) James Ashcroft (Coroner) Genevieve Buechner (Lily Shoemaker) William Taylor (Detective Jackson Riley) Marnette Patterson (Charlie) Adrianne Palicki (Jessica Moore)

WB Description

In suburban Nebraska, a group of partying high school teens jokingly dare their friend Charlie (guest star Marnette Patterson) to look into the mirror and repeat 'Bloody Mary, Bloody Mary, Bloody Mary," not knowing this will unleash a series of mysterious murders. Sam (Jared Padalecki) and Dean (Jensen Ackles) realize that Bloody Mary has the power to travel through all reflective surfaces when she is hunting a victim. Worried that teens are accidentally summoning Bloody Mary, Sam and Dean race to destroy the violent spirit before she can kill again.

Full Synopsis

Toledo, Ohio: House: Focusing in on a girl party, three young girls are having a slumber party and playing "Truth or Dare". One girls asks another girl, Lilly, an embarassing "would you want to make out with..." question. Lilly doesn't answer it and is forced to do a dare. The dare was to say "Bloody Mary" 3 times in the bathroom, which Lilly does and is scared when her 2 friends shake the door in order to scare her. Then Lilly's dad, Steven Shoemaker, asks them to quiet down, then he goes into the bathroom, looks in a mirror and his eyes start to bleed. An older sister walks in "past curfew" and goes upstairs and sees her father on the floor, dead.

Dreamland: Sam dreams about when her saw his girlfriend, murdered. He then wakes up by Dean.

Dean's Car: Dean and Sam discuss Sam's reoccuring nightmare. They found a newspaper article for SHOEMAKER, Steven the murder victim and decide to go check things out.

Morge 144: Dean and Sam pass a desk of a "DR D. FEIKLOWICZ" and walk to a man. They say they are "medical interns" and that Dr. Feiklowicz is there to show them the Shoemaker corpse. Unfortunate,ly Dr. Feilklowicz wasn't in that day. The man does not let them through, that is, until Sam takes out Dean's money in order to bribe the man.

Now able to see the corpse, they interrogate the man. They see the corpse's eyes have "liquify." The medical report blames it on a stroke or anorism. Now after they bring out more money they see the police report and decide to go to the daughters.

Shoemaker's House: Back at the house, a wake is in session. Dean and Sam go to the daughter that found her dad, Donna. They said they "worked with her father". They asked if they noticed any symptons. The younger daughter, Lilly interrupted and said that it was her fault and explained the Sam and Dean that she said "Bloody Mary."

Death Scene: Dean and Sam go to the bathroom and talk about Bloody Mary. They don't understand why the father was killed. Donna's friend, Charley, walks up to the bathroom and interrogates Sam and Dean. She explains to them that Donn'a s father was a day-trader and worked by himself. She is on to them and they come clean.

Central Library: They realize there are many stories on the Bloody Mary legend. They do know that they all have something in common that she always named Mary and you have to say her name 3 times.

Charley's Car/Jill's Room(Phone): Charley told Jill the truth about Sam and Dean via phone, which Jill only cared about how they were goodlooking. They also talk about the "Bloody Mary" legend, which Jill feels its a hoax, so she says Bloody Mary 3 times in the mirror and screams to trick Charley into thinking something has happened to her. She laughs and hangs up the phone. Only moments later is when Jill looks into a mirror and her eyes start to bleed.

Next Day, Hotel: Sam wakes up with the same nightmare, again. He looks over to Dean and asks if he has found anything on the Bloody Mary case. Unforchanately, he hasn't. They get a called from Charley with something important.

School: They find Charley and ask her some questions about the death of Jill. Charley confesses that Jill said "Bloody Mary" 3 times and then asks them if they think the "Bloody Mary" legend is real. They tell her that they think it is, which doesn't make Charley feel any better.

Jill's house: With the aid of Charley, Sam and Dean are able to get into Jill's room. They turn off all the lights and use a black light on the mirror in Jill's room. On the back of the mirror the blacklight revealed it said Gary Bryman along with a handprint.

Back at school: Sam does his research and discovers that Gary Bryman was an eight year old boy, who was killed in a hit and run. Charley confesses that Jill drove the same car that was described in the hit and run.

Shoemaker's House: Now back at the shoemaker residence they do the same blacklight test to another mirror and it reveals the name "Linda Shoemaker" with the same hand print. Sam and Dean then go to Donna to question her if she knows anything about Linda. Donna says that Linda was her mom that died by overdosing and then she asks them to leave. They think that Donna's dad killed her mom. Jill said that she was going to stay with Donna.

Hotel: Dean is doing a nation-wide search to find any connection between deaths and the name "Mary." They discover that Mary must have a pattern in choosing her victims, killing someone and keeping it secret. Thanks to Dean doing a check he discovers "Mary Worthington" who had the same handprint like on the mirrors.

Fort Wayne, Indiana: They go to a guy that knows about her murder, Dean and Sam say they are reporters. The man says that the Worthington murder still confuses him. They ask the guy what he thinks happened with the murder, because apparently someone killed her by cutting her eyes out. Before she died he believes that she was trying to spell the name of her killer. She spelt "tre" on a mirror so one of the suspects was a surgent and his name was, Trevor. Mary kepted a journal and said she was seeing a man she called "T" and was going to tell his wife about there affair. The man says her eyes were cut out almost were professionally but never had enough proof or any witnesses. They asked if the mirror that she spelt the three letters on were still around but the man had no further information.

School, Bathroom: Charley meets Donna in the bathroom and Donna yells at Charley for bringing Dean and Sam to her house. Also Donna still doesn't believe in the whole "Bloody Mary" superstition so she says Bloody Mary three times in front of the mirror and Charley is scared.

School, Classroom: As Charley walks to class Bloody Mary is in a window that Charley walks past. Once in class Charley looks into her mirror in her pocketbook and notices her eyes start to bleed. She starts to make a scene as she gets up and any reflective surface. including her teacher's glasses, she sees Bloody Mary. She then throws a chair through a window.

Dean's Car:They get information on the mirror and coincidentally the mirror was sold to a shop in town. Dean and Sam then get a call from Charley so they rush over to find her.

Hotel:Back and the hotel Sam and Dean cover all the reflective objects in the hotel room. Charley is afriad of her death but Sam and Dean assure her that nothing will happen to her. Charley confesses about her boyfriends death that wasn't entirely her fault, she did not kill him yet her boyfriend killed himself over her.

Dean's Car: Sam and Dean discuss how to stop Mary. They figure that they have to smash the mirror that Mary first inhabited. They needed someone to summon her and Sam offers himself. Dean the pulls over to the side and askes if its about Jessica. Dean tells Sam that it was not his fault because of Jessica's death. Sam feels that he could have warned her and also reveals he hasn't told Dean somethings. Dean questions what it is but Sam refuses to tell. Dean still forbids it but Sam reminds Dean of Charley.

Mirror Shop: They are able to pick the lock and infultrate the shop. They realieze it will be hard to find the mirror as they look around. During the search they set off an alarm. They find the mirror and Sam says "Bloody Mary" three times. They notice a light from outside. Dean goes outside to check it out and tells Sam to smash anything he sees move.

Shop, Outside: Dean goes outside and sees two police officers. Dean says he is the shop-owners kid.

Meanwhile(Sam): Sam starts to smash mirrors and taunts Mary to come into the one she has to. Eventually Sam's eyes start to bleed and he drops down his weapon. Mary taunts Sam now saying that he killed Jessica.

Meanwhile(Dean): Makes an excuse that he was "adopted". Eventually he decides to cut the small talk and knock out the two officiers.

Back Inside: Mary to continues to taunt Sam saying that he had dreams before the incident actually happens. Luckily Dean comes in to intervene and smashes the mirror. Unforchanately Mary's reign doesn't end there, her dead body actually comes out of the mirror. Now both Sam and Dean's eye bleed, that is, until Dean gets a mirror so to reserve the effect back to her. Her eyes bleed and essentially turns into blood.

Dean's Car: Dean and Sam drive Charley back to her house and they assure her that she is safe. She exits the car and leaves the house.

Sam and Dean drive off but Dean asks Sam if he can tell him what the secret was. Sam responds by saying that there are somethings he needs to keep to himself. While driving Sam sees his dead girlfriend, Jessica, that disappears shortly after.

Synopsis by RealityCheck

Episode Music

"Laugh, I Nearly Died"  by The Rolling Stones
"Sugar, We're Going Down"  by Fall Out Boy 
"Rock Of Ages"  by Def Leppard

Extras

Episode Promos Episode Review Episode Screencaps WB Trailer  Inside the Legend Audio Clips


Video Clips

Bad Luck

Exploding eyeballs

Paris Hilton

Bloody Mary